The Attention Economy: We’re Solving the Wrong Problem

Written by Valerie Morrow, Dairy Farmers of America | Nov 12, 2026, 2:21:30 PM

About this article:
How do you earn attention when everyone is exhausted and skeptical? In the Attention Economy, a marketing leader gets real about what is actually cutting through right now — the hard-won truths from the trenches, not the frameworks from a deck.

Everyone is fighting for attention. More content, shorter hooks, faster edits, better targeting. And now AI can help us produce all of it at a speed we couldn’t have imagined a few years ago.

But I’m beginning to think attention isn’t really the scarce resource.

Believability is.

Think about what we’re asking people to do every time they scroll: Is this an ad? Is this person being paid? Is that claim exaggerated? Was this written by AI? Is that even a real person? Who benefits from me believing this?

That’s exhausting. People don’t want to be skeptical; we’ve given them plenty of reasons to be. And when nearly anyone can create polished content in seconds, polish isn’t always the trust signal marketers think it is.

There’s an opportunity in that, but it requires us to listen better. And I don’t mean checking the social listening dashboard before Monday’s status meeting.

Good listening means understanding where your audience actually is, not assuming they’ve already arrived where your marketing plan needs them to be. Sometimes we’re ready to talk about a benefit while they’re still trying to understand how it’s even possible. Sometimes there’s a question they want answered but feel silly asking. Then a brand shows up, knows they had the question, finds someone who can answer it from experience, and explains it in a way that makes sense.

Timing matters, too. You can know where you want the ball to go, but if the receiver isn’t open yet, throwing it anyway doesn’t make it a good pass. Sometimes listening means holding the content until the audience is ready instead of forcing every post to carry the entire brand message.

We’ve seen this play out at Dairy Farmers of America (DFA). We shared several ways dairy farmers practice stewardship, including recycling manure solids for cow bedding. The format couldn’t unpack every part of the process, but it gave people enough information to become curious.

And they had questions: Wait. Cows sleep in their own waste? How does that work?

Our audience showed us where they wanted another layer of information, so we partnered with a farmer-owner of DFA who uses recycled manure bedding to show how it works. We compared the role heat plays in helping sanitize the bedding to something most of us already understand: the way your dishwasher uses heat to sanitize dishes.

Then he said the finished bedding was so clean he’d let his own kids play in it. And we showed them doing exactly that.

That moment gets at what I think people are increasingly looking for from brands: You knew the question I had. You found someone who had earned the right to answer it. And you explained it in a way I could understand and believe.

A comment section can be the beginning of the next piece of content, not a report card on the last one.

It’s one reason we’ve built a network of DFA farmer-owner content creators, employee advocates, and subject matter experts. The brand doesn’t always need to be the one doing the talking. Sometimes the most believable person is the one who actually does the work every day.

But putting the right person in front of the camera is only part of it.

The goal is to prepare people enough to be useful without scripting them so tightly that we polish away what made them believable in the first place.

When information feels cheap and abundant, producing more of it isn’t the advantage. Understanding what someone actually needs, connecting them with a credible human perspective, and making the answer genuinely useful is.

Content is only getting easier to produce.

Trust isn’t.

As we plan for 2027, I’m challenging my team to think harder about what deserves someone’s attention, who has earned the right to speak, and what makes an answer believable.

We have more ways than ever to get attention. Earning it is still the job.